From
"The Broken American Male - And How to Fix Him" by Rabbi Shmuley Boteach:
Another
New York
hedge-fund manager with whom I am friendly came to see me to discuss a shocking
secret. Married for twenty years, he was in the midst of a destructive affair
from which he wished to extricate himself He was asking me how to do so and how
to tell his wife. I had always thought he had a very happy marriage. This is a
man who makes, without exaggeration, about fifty million dollars a year in fees
from his fund. He is enormously successful. "What was missing in your
life that you felt the need to do this?" I asked him. He told me that one
day he was reading the Time - the magazine's annual list of the one
hundred most influential people in the world - and saw one of his acquaintances
on the list in the business category. Like him, his colleague was a hedge-fund
manager. "Shmuley, I felt like a failure. I'm
forty-eight years old, and here is this guy I know who's voted one of the
hundred most influential people in the world. And who has even ever heard of
me? I guess, after that, I was really vulnerable. My secretary saw my
depression and we started talking every day, and one thing led to
another." Incredible. A man with everything was
throwing his blessings away because he wasn't on a magazine list.
I had
something of a reverse experience with lists. In April 2007 Newsweek magazine
published a list of the fifty most influential rabbis in America. The
list put me at number nine, and then added that I had been called "the
most famous rabbi in America."
That day media calls poured in for comment. What did it feel like to be the
best known rabbi and among the top ten in influence? Truth be told, it felt
good, but also horrible, and I said so. I mentioned that the list was probably
corrosive. And why? Because I knew that now I, and the
forty-nine others on the list, would feel enormous pressure to make sure we
were on the list the following year as well. Our value as rabbis, as spiritual
leaders, had been given a number value, a quotient. The list would also ensure
that we chose to do the kind of work that got noticed so that we would be on
the list the following year, as would all those unnoticed rabbis who had not
made this year's list. What would happen to all the unspoken, quiet acts of
kindness and counseling that rabbis do every year, which are the true stuff of
greatness? Would they just be lost? I write these lines just two months after
the list came out. It's done nothing for me other than give me a brief ego
boost and leave me in anxiety about my standing in
spiritual America.
But our country is obsessed with lists. We love them, we live for them.
Everything in America
has a price tag, everything can be given a numerical
value, especially human beings. There's one problem. People are of infinite
value, and when they are reduced to a place on a list, even when they are at
the top of the list, they are regressing.